New ebookThe Sauce: the downloadable pricing ebook for agents and loan officers. Look up any pricing problem in seconds.: the pricing ebook for agents and loan officers. Instant download.$97 · Download →
Estates, Trusts & Divorce

What is a date-of-death appraisal, and why does the IRS care about the date?

Share this
Cartoon of the appraiser pointing at one date circled in coral on a big wall calendar while later pages fly off and Comps the basset hound holds a sign that says This Day.
Later pages can blow away. The value stays on the circled date.
The short answer

A date-of-death appraisal values a home as of the day the owner died, even if the report is written months later. The date matters because federal tax law generally sets an heir's basis at the home's fair market value on that day. The appraiser uses the sales, trend and condition that existed then, not today.

The tax rule comes with a date stapled to it

Most appraisals answer "what is this house worth?" A date-of-death appraisal answers "what was this house worth on one exact day?" That one extra phrase is the whole job.

The reason is in the tax code. Under section 1014, the basis of property you inherit is generally its fair market value at the date of the decedent's death. If the executor elects the alternate valuation date under section 2032, the basis is the value on that later date instead. The IRS says the date-of-death rule applies whether or not an estate tax return is filed.

Basis is what you subtract from the sale price to find your gain. Pick the wrong day and you are measuring your gain from the wrong starting line. The IRS is not interested in the day the family finally got around to calling someone.

For the full basics of inherited basis, see Do I need a date of death appraisal for an inherited house? This post is about the date itself, and why it changes everything about how the appraisal gets built.

Move the date and the evidence changes

An appraisal has two dates. The effective date is the day the value applies to. The report date is the day the appraiser signs it. In a date-of-death appraisal, also called a retrospective appraisal, the effective date sits in the past and the report date is today.

Once the effective date is set, it decides four things:

  • Which sales count. The comparable sales (comps) are the ones a buyer could have seen on that date: sales that had closed, plus listings and pending sales that were on the market then.
  • What the market was doing. Prices rising, flat or falling as of that day, measured with the most recent window the data supports at that time.
  • What the house was like. The kitchen, the roof and the stained ceiling as they were that day, not after the cleanup crew and the painter.
  • What was known. A buyer on that date could not know about a road project announced six months later. Neither can the appraisal.

Here is a hypothetical. Say a home's owner passed in early spring, and prices in the neighborhood fell over the summer. The heirs call in the fall. The value they need is the spring value, before the slide. If prices had climbed instead, the spring value would still be the one that counts. The calendar does not care which answer the family prefers.

What happens to sales that closed after the date

This is where a lot of retrospective reports go wrong in one direction or the other.

A sale that closed after the date of death was not something a buyer on that day could see. It cannot be the reason the value is what it is. But it is not useless either. Guidance under the appraisal standards, as quoted by the International Society of Appraisers, says data after the effective date may be considered as a confirmation of trends that a buyer or seller would reasonably have considered as of that date.

In plain words: later sales can back up a trend I already measured. They cannot create one that was not visible yet.

When I chart the market in these reports, I show both periods. The trend up to the date of death is drawn solid, because that is what the value rests on. The months after are drawn differently and labeled as context only. You get to see what happened next, and you can see that the value did not borrow from it.

A value as of today is a different assignment

Families often ask for one number that does two jobs: set the tax basis and tell them what to list the house for. Those are two questions with two effective dates.

  • The basis question is answered as of the date of death, with the house in its condition on that date.
  • The listing question is answered as of today, with the house as it stands now, after any cleanout or repairs.

Both can come out of one engagement, but they are separate opinions with separate support. A value as of any later date is a different assignment, not an update to the first one.

The same goes for online estimates. A number pulled up this week answers a question about this week. It never saw the house, and it is not looking at the right day.

The date also has to match the paperwork. If an estate tax return is filed and the executor sends a Schedule A to Form 8971, the IRS says you may need to use a basis consistent with that final estate tax value, and a penalty can apply if you claim more. The appraisal and the return should be telling the same story about the same day.

What to gather, sorted by date

Retrospective work runs on dated evidence. Here is what helps most, in the order I would ask for it:

  1. The exact date of death, from the death certificate. Everything keys off it.
  2. Photos from as close to that date as possible. Phone photos, holiday pictures, a video call screenshot. File dates help.
  3. Old listing photos if the house was ever on the market. They show finishes and layout.
  4. A dated list of changes since then. Repairs, cleanouts, removals, upgrades. What happened, and roughly when.
  5. Documents with dates on them: permits, inspection reports, insurance claims, repair bids and any prior appraisal.
  6. Whether an estate tax return is being filed, and whether you need a second value for the alternate valuation date.

This is general information, and tax treatment depends on your facts, so confirm your basis and dates with your CPA or tax attorney.

What I see in the field

Estate and trust work is a big part of my practice. The most common worry I hear is that waiting too long ruined the appraisal. Usually it did not. The sales from that date are still on record. The job is to rebuild the house as it was and price it against the market as it stood.

The more common problem is drift. A report says "as of the date of death" on page one, then uses a trend that runs right through to last month, or describes the new floors. That is a today value wearing a date-of-death name tag.

A good retrospective report teaches the reader the market on that day. It names the sales, shows the trend up to the date, explains each adjustment, and says plainly how condition was established. When a CPA can follow it without calling me, the date did its job.

Key takeaways

  • An inherited home's basis is generally its fair market value on the date of death.
  • The effective date sets which sales, which trend and which condition the appraisal uses.
  • Later sales can confirm a trend but cannot create the value.
  • A value as of today is a separate assignment with its own support.
  • Dated photos and documents are the best evidence a family can give the appraiser.
Share this
Newsletters to your inbox

Get the best posts once a week.

Priced Right is one email a week with the most useful appraisal and pricing posts and what the market is doing. Never more than one a week. Unsubscribe anytime.

People also ask

Can a date-of-death appraisal be done years later?

Yes. The effective date is in the past, but the report can be written later. What limits it is whether enough evidence survives about the house and the market on that date.

Does the appraiser need to go inside the house?

It helps, but the house may have changed since the date of death. Dated photos and records often matter more than what the house looks like today.

What if the house was sold soon after the death?

An arm's-length sale close to the date can be strong evidence. If an estate tax return is involved, the alternate valuation rules treat property sold within six months differently, so ask your CPA.

Sources

About the author

Anthony Young is a California Certified Residential Appraiser (License AR041465) with more than 25 years in residential valuation, offices in the San Francisco Bay Area and Southern California, and a national educator who teaches agents and loan officers how value really works. This article is general information, not legal, tax or lending advice.

Ask Anthony

Got a question we haven't answered?

Suggest a topic or ask your own appraisal question. The best ones become posts.