New ebookThe Sauce: the downloadable pricing ebook for agents and loan officers. Look up any pricing problem in seconds.: the pricing ebook for agents and loan officers. Instant download.$97 · Download →
Second opinions

Appraisal reviews and second opinions in California.

Have questions about an appraisal? We review it against the market, impartially, in either direction. You get a clear answer on whether the report holds up, and what you need for a reconsideration of value if it does not.

Anthony Young, California Certified Residential Appraiser, License AR041465. 25+ years in residential valuation. Serving all of California from San Ramon.

The short answer

What a desktop review tells you.

A desktop review is a second opinion on an appraisal someone else wrote. We check its conclusions against the evidence and tell you plainly whether it holds up.

Findings that lowered the value without support are listed one by one, each backed with paired sales by address. Every other error is listed separately. Our fee does not depend on the result.

Three kinds of evidence move an appraiser in a reconsideration of value: a factual error with proof, a closed sale the report missed with a clear reason it is more similar, and an adjustment that lowered the value without market support.

Who orders it

When a number does not look right.

IListing and buyer agents. A low appraisal can sink a deal. Find out if it holds up.
IILoan officers. Know whether an ROV has a real chance before you file it.
IIIHomeowners. Get an independent read before you argue with anyone.
IVAttorneys. Check the other side's report in a dispute.
VAnyone before an ROV. Lead with the evidence that actually moves appraisers.
What you get

A narrative report that shows the work.

A review written as if it would be forwarded straight to the original appraiser, with snapshots of the report pages behind each finding.

  • A short executive summary up front
  • Each unsupported finding numbered, with paired sales by address
  • Other errors listed separately, so the main issues stay clear
  • Snapshots of the report page behind each finding
  • What a reconsideration of value can use, and what it cannot
How it works

From first call to signed report.

1Send the report. The full appraisal PDF and the contract, if there is one.
2We test it against the market. Sales, trend, adjustments and the facts of the house.
3You get the findings. Numbered, sourced and ready to forward.
4You decide the next step. An ROV, a negotiation or moving on.
Before you call

What to have ready.

You do not need all of it. Send what you have and we will tell you what else would help.

  • The full appraisal report as a PDF
  • The purchase contract, if it is a sale
  • Any sales you think the appraiser missed, with addresses
  • Facts the report got wrong, with proof
  • Your lender's ROV deadline, if there is one
Common questions

What agents and homeowners ask.

Request a second opinion
Can I get a second appraisal if the first one is low?

Sometimes, but a low number alone is not a reason. Under Freddie Mac's rules, a lender may order a new appraisal only for documented signs the first one is inaccurate, not credible or discriminatory, under a set review policy, or when law requires it.

What is a reconsideration of value?

A formal request, sent through your lender, asking the appraiser to look again at the value because of factual errors or relevant sales the report did not consider. On Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans you get one borrower ROV per appraisal, before closing, with up to five alternative comparable sales.

Can the agent send the ROV straight to the appraiser?

No. The request goes through the lender, which reviews it first and then sends it to the appraiser in a standard format.

Does your fee depend on finding a problem?

No. Our fee does not depend on the result. If the report holds up, we tell you that too.

Can the value go down after an ROV?

An ROV asks the appraiser to consider new facts. If those facts point lower, the appraiser has to report that honestly, so only submit evidence you have checked.

Where we work

Statewide, with local market data.

We take this work across California, including the Bay Area, Sacramento, the Central Valley, the Central Coast and Southern California. See the counties we serve.