Is your California home worth less than its assessed value?
If your home's market value on the January 1 lien date was lower than its Prop 13 factored base year value, Proposition 8 lets the county assessor enroll the lower number for that year. You can ask the assessor for an informal review, or file a formal appeal with the county appeals board during the filing window.
Prop 13 sets your base. Prop 8 is the safety valve.
Most California homeowners know Prop 13. Your assessed value starts at what the home was worth when you bought it or built it. Then it can rise each year, but by no more than 2 percent. The State Board of Equalization (BOE) calls that adjusted number your factored base year value.
Proposition 8 passed in November 1978, a few months after Prop 13. It is now in Revenue and Taxation Code section 51. It covers the opposite problem: what happens when the market falls below that factored number.
The BOE explains the rule this way. Each year, the assessor enrolls the lower of two values: your factored base year value, or the home's market value on January 1. When market value is lower, that is a "decline in value," and you get taxed on the lower number.
If you want the bigger picture on why your tax number and your appraisal rarely match, start with appraised value vs assessed value in California. This post is about the years when the market dips under your tax number. It happens. Usually right after everyone at the barbecue swore prices only go up.
The only date that counts is January 1
The BOE calls January 1 the lien date. A decline in value exists in a year when your home's market value on that date is below its factored base year value. For example, county assessors describe the January 1, 2026 value as the one that sets the 2026–27 assessment.
That means today's value does not matter for this question. If prices dropped in March, that is next year's problem. If prices climbed back by summer, your January 1 value can still be low. The tax year looks at one snapshot, like a school photo. Whatever your hair was doing that morning is on record.
Evidence has a time limit too. The BOE says the appeals board may not consider comparable sales that happened more than 90 days after the date your value was set. It also says the sales closest in time are the best indicators of value. So the strongest case uses sales of similar homes that closed shortly before or after January 1.
I like this rule. It forces everyone to read the market as of a real date, not a vague year. That is how I price every assignment anyway: test the most recent window the data supports, then state the value as of one day.
Informal review vs formal appeal
There are two paths. Most people should try the first one before the second.
| Informal review | Formal appeal | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | The county assessor's staff | The county assessment appeals board, or the board of supervisors sitting as one |
| How to start | The assessor's own review request form | The county's version of form BOE-305-AH, filed with the clerk of the board |
| When | Set by each county, often early in the year | July 2 to September 15, or to November 30 in some counties |
| Cost | Check your county | Some counties charge a filing fee |
The BOE suggests talking to the assessor's office first. If the assessor agrees, it can be settled there without a hearing. Informal review windows are set county by county, and some close early, so look up your county's dates.
An informal review is not an appeal. If the assessor does not agree with you, the BOE says you can then appeal to the appeals board. That only works if your application is filed inside the appeal window. Missing it is the property tax version of showing up to the open house the day after it closed.
The filing window depends on your county
For a regular lien date appeal, Revenue and Taxation Code section 1603 sets the window at July 2 to September 15. The deadline moves to November 30 in counties where the assessor does not mail the required assessment notice by August 1. The BOE confirms the window is one or the other "depending upon the county in which you are located."
A few more details from the statute and the BOE:
- An application mailed and postmarked by the deadline counts as filed on time.
- If the last day falls on a weekend or holiday, a postmark on the next business day counts.
- The law allows up to two years to resolve an application. If it is not heard in that time, your opinion of value may temporarily become the taxable value by default.
- For an owner-occupied single-family home that is your main residence, the BOE says the assessor carries the burden of proof. In most other appeals, the applicant does.
Check your county clerk of the board's website for the exact dates this year. Do not trust your neighbor's memory. He also thinks his garage counts as square footage.
What happens to your value next year
A Prop 8 reduction is temporary. The BOE says the assessor reviews it every year to decide if the home is still in decline status.
Here is the part that surprises people. While your home is in decline status, its assessed value can go up by more than 2 percent a year. The BOE says it can never go above your factored base year value, unless there is a change in ownership or new construction.
A hypothetical shows how this works. Say your factored base year value is $950,000. Similar homes nearby sold for about $880,000 around January 1, so the assessor enrolls $880,000. The next January, sales point to $990,000. Your assessed value can jump back up, but only to your factored base. If that base rose the full 2 percent, that is $969,000, not $990,000.
So a Prop 8 cut is a discount, not a reset. Prop 13 is still in the background, keeping score with a calculator and a long memory.
How to build a case that holds up
- Find your factored base year value. It is on your assessment notice or the assessor's website. If the market was not below it on January 1, there is no Prop 8 case.
- Pull sales near January 1. Use homes like yours: same area, similar size, age, condition and lot. Closed sales beat listings. Remember the 90-day limit after the value date.
- Adjust for real differences. A sale with a new kitchen is not proof your 1990s kitchen is worth the same. Differences should be measured from sales, not guessed.
- Check the assessor's facts. Square footage, bedrooms, baths and lot size. A wrong record can be its own issue.
- Ask for an informal review first. Bring your sales in a short, clean list.
- Calendar the appeal window anyway. July 2 to September 15 or November 30, depending on your county.
Where an appraisal helps: when the gap is large, the home is unusual, or you are headed to a hearing. A retrospective appraisal can be written as of January 1, using the sales the board is allowed to see. I build those as narrative reports that show each sale and each adjustment, so a board member can follow the logic without taking my word for it. You can find that work on my services page. For questions about your tax bill itself, talk with your CPA or a property tax attorney.
Key takeaways
- Prop 8 lets the assessor enroll your January 1 market value when it is below your factored base year value.
- Only the January 1 lien date counts, and sales more than 90 days after it cannot be considered by the appeals board.
- Try an informal review first, but file a formal appeal inside your county's window to keep that option.
- The formal window is July 2 to September 15, or to November 30 in some counties.
- A reduction is reviewed every year and can climb back up to your factored base.
Get the best posts once a week.
Priced Right is one email a week with the most useful appraisal and pricing posts and what the market is doing. Never more than one a week. Unsubscribe anytime.
People also ask
Do I have to file a new request every year?
The BOE says the assessor reviews homes in decline status each year. If you disagree with a later year's value, you need to raise it for that year, inside that year's review or appeal window.
Can I hire someone to file for me?
Yes. Section 1603 refers to applications filed by the owner or the owner's agent. Check your county's form for what an agent has to include. The informal review is often simple enough to do yourself if you have good sales near January 1.
Does a Prop 8 reduction change what my house would sell for?
No. It only changes the value used for that year's property tax. Buyers price the house from sales, not from your tax bill.
Sources
- California State Board of Equalization: Decline in Value, Proposition 8
- California State Board of Equalization: Assessment Appeals Frequently Asked Questions
- California Revenue and Taxation Code section 1603 (appeal filing period)
- Sonoma County Assessor: Value Decline (example of a county review process)
Got a question we haven't answered?
Suggest a topic or ask your own appraisal question. The best ones become posts.